Well, you see, we did see it, as it was neither abusive nor obscene, which is all Dale is trying to prevent. And remember, on the few occasions Dale has booted someone from the list, there have generally been offlist messages sent to list members even less acceptable than the postings everyone saw. When a member receives an abusive offlist message in response to a list posting, that is a legitimate concern for Dale as well. I have some pretty strong opinions myself, but I recognize the need to state them in acceptable terms in public or when emailing a person I disagree with. This is my second posting in defense of Dale's policy, and I think that is enough, so I'll now give it a rest and return to the subject of classic bikes.
Regards,
Jerry Moos
Steven L. Sheffield wrote:
> Dale (and list-members) --
>
> In my rather strong (and definitely not humble) opinion, moderation of a
> mailing list equates to censorship ... either actual or implied. I prefer a
> free exchange of ideas, and if people get insulted, so be it. Insult me
> back. It's just words ... it's not like we're coming after each other with
> a stick.
>
> If someone crosses the line too many times, I don't have an issue with
> asking them to leave ... but in general, I'm a firm believer in judicious
> use of the delete key. If I don't care for what someone says, I delete it.
> If I don't want to read other messages by that person, I filter them
> directly into the trash ... but I don't feel it should EVER be up to any one
> person to decide what I should and should not, and can and cannot read.
>
> I'm truly irked by Dale's decision to take this step ... just because one
> person has a problem with Ray Etherton and Mike Kone. My big question is
> whether or not any of the CR list-members (besides Dale) will even see this
> message.