I: [CR]Now:Where did all the French Component Manufacturers GoWas:Loving old bikes despite their shortcomings

(Example: Component Manufacturers:Ideale)

Date: Wed, 28 Aug 2002 22:54:21 -0500
From: "The Maaslands" <TheMaaslands@comcast.net>
Subject: I: [CR]Now:Where did all the French Component Manufacturers GoWas:Loving old bikes despite their shortcomings
To: Classic Rendezvous <Classicrendezvous@bikelist.org>


Lou Deeter wrote:
> I think all of those smart French component engineers who understood metallurgy and stuff like that migrated to the French automobile industry to build Citroens, Renaults and Peugeots. By the way, anybody know of a French car that is imported into the U.S. now? Hmmmm, for that matter, how many Italian cars are imported into the U.S. now.......I'm still searching for classic content on this, but...

There are more French and Italian cars in the US than American cars in either Italy or France. French and Italian cars are also sold in more countries than are the big 3 Americans. What does that signify to you? What about engineering prowess you ask! Have you ever looked at the two most universally accepted examples of engineering expertise in automotive competition and the big winners. In Formula 1, the big engineering prowess comes from Britain (virtually all modern Formula 1 teams are based there) France (See the dominance of Renault engines for close to a decade) and Italy (Ferrari). In World Rally Cars, the true leaders over the last 30 years have been almost exclusively French and Italian: Citroen, Peugeot and Alpine from France and Lancia (a division of Fiat) from Italy. Were it not for German Ford, Subaru and Mitsubishi, you would need to go back to the 60's to find anybody but Italians and French winning the world championship. Lancia's wins alone outdo all non-French or Italian brands wins.

With regards to bicycle equipment, the French do indeed have a valid history of engineering firsts. What they lacked were the marketing prowess of Tullio Campagnolo and his love of his area of expertise. As the French watchmaker, Alain Silberstein, so poignantly puts it: Happiness is to have one's passion as a profession. (see http://www.a-silberstein.fr/us/accueil.htm) They also did not have the goods to satisfy the big buyers either as has already been mentioned. Dealing with one French supplier is bad enough, but needing to speak to 5, no thanks!! If I could put together a modern-day 'dream bike' today that also required a certain degree of rational thought, I would most certainly include a number of French components. I'd put French Look pedals, Stronglight headset, Sedis/Sachs chain, Mavic rims and Michelin Fond de Jante. The same can be said about almost every decade of lightweight bicycle history. Jan's comments about the Maxicar hubs are very true and also speak of the Pelissier hubs before that. The Simplex and Huret gears were well ahead of Campagnolo for many years. The Stronglight and TA chainsets, the Mafac brakes... I believe the Japanese are very correct in their love of the vintage French bikes and components.

Steven Maasland Moorestown, NJ

---