Re: [CR] Restorations

(Example: Racing:Beryl Burton)

From: <"kohl57@starpower.net">
To: classicrendezvous@bikelist.org
Subject: Re: [CR] Restorations
Date: Mon, 29 Nov 2004 10:07:01 -0500


To me a nicely restored bicycle is the sum of its parts. I look for harmony of era rather than how shiny the bits might be. To me, it's jarring to see an otherwise beautifully restored (or indeed original condition) 1950s cycle with out of date components. My eyes are going to focus on those modern Look pedals and the new saddle, the bright orange brake pads, modern clincher instead of tubular tyres rather than the spot-on correct Reynolds transfer or the lugwork picked out in gold. All of these modern bits may be more "efficient" than the originals but they just destroy the integrity of the thing. At least in my eyes. A Terry's watch holder: add points. Modern cycle computer: take off points.

Of course, this personal prejudice colours my opinion even of perfectly authentic vintage machines. Not long ago, Hilary Stone had a simply lovely, quite original Stallaird Monthlery... it was "as found" and as last ridden. But this 1949 machine had been progressively "updated" by its owner as so many bikes were and presented a mishmash of 1950s-60s components. If I had bought it (and I was sorely tempted!) I admit I would have changed all of the components back to c. 1949. Is this "valid" restoration?? Maybe not. But like so much we do, it's a mix of valid restoration "practice" (defined by whom?!) and personal preference. I err to the side of going back to "specs" or at least to a defined year or era.

But whatever we do, it's gotta be better than seeing this stuff compacted at the recyling depot. 'cause thats still the fate of most classic bicycles, even very good ones. That's far more distressing than the occasional overpriced pieces of junk that pop up on eBay or the misbegotten "restoration" we might turn our noises up at.

Peter Kohler Washington DC USA

--------------------------------------------------------------------
mail2web - Check your email from the web at
http://mail2web.com/ .