I wouldn;t expect CR listers to get all excited about white leather saddles. I thought that was more for the younger FGG types. Not that there's anything wrong with them and their aesthetic and/or money.
Just a note about the pink and white saddles from that China maker (BTW- are you sure it's China and not Taiwan?). While the brown and black ones are tanned like a brooks or Lepper, the lighter colored ones are 'coated' , ie spray painted or powder coated.
I have a couple Taiwan made white leather saddles and was disappointed that they were spray painted. It would wear off in 50-60 miles. I passed on importing them for that reason alone.
But they did look pretty cool.
1817 George ave
Annapolis MD 21401